I have no good evidence in the subject "Is Ram a Vegetarian ?" Unlike the Abrahamic religions, it is not a one book religion. In the chapter 36 of Sundara-kanda, Hanuman assures Mother Sita that Lord Rama would cross over the ocean and defeat Ravana. Under the incumbent right-wing regime, instances of these ethos being unilaterally imposed, are becoming alarmingly prevalent. It is just shaped like animal and that is good enough. Did Lord Rama eat meat? | The Spiritual Scientist Maams also mean fruit pulp, as it is used in South Indian temples. Any issues to be expected to with Port of Entry Process. ]"Be comfortable for a moment, here it is possible for you to make a sojourn, and soon my husband will be coming on taking plentiful forest produce, and on killing stags, mongooses, wild boars he fetches meat, aplenty. What did Rama eat during Vanvas? - Your Sage Tip By citing several scriptures it can be shown that our seers or iis were used to meat eating. You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments! To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. 13,117.038a ahis paramo yajas tathhis para balam Yes. m gdha kasya svid dhanam. "Raghava, five kinds of five-nailed animals, viz., a kind of wild rodent, a kind of wild-boar, a kind of lizard, a hare and fifthly the turtle are edible for Brahmans and Kshatriya-s. [4-17-39], Hindu's Holy Books were EDITED By Britishers. people use same twisting logic to say brahmins ate beef in olden days. So from these some people infer that this means that Lord Ram would normally eat meat but in the jungle He decided to stop eating meat. Any issues to be expected to with Port of Entry Process? He tries to trick her into crossing the bewitched demarcation, an impregnable threshold marked by Lakshmana. this was a question asked by many during preaching but i didnt have a 100% perfect answer. Diversely coloured, amazingly limbed, and spotted with gemlike dapples it is shining forth like a deer that is completely gemmy, and while nonchalantly moving before me it is enlivening the forest like the moon. Stating his opinion in Anusana-parva of the Mahbhrata, this is what Bhma says: It is even so, O mighty-armed one, as thou sayest. Does consuming non-vegetarian food hinder our spiritual progress? Souless remake unmakes soulful epic, Adipurusha movie: Ramayana: Modernized or minimized? Where did Rama kill deer? So therefore, within the vedic literature itself, there is a tradition of how the scriptures are to be understood and that is not by cheripaking verses here and there and interpreting them according to ones own pre-conceptions and without considering the context of the scriptures. [3-47-22b, 23], |, || --, 32. atha = then; viiryavaan raamaH = resolute one, Rama; saha saumitriH = with, Soumitri; vanam yaatvaa = to forest, on going; sthuulaan mahaa rohiin hatvaa = robust-bodied, big, Rohi [or, Kesari animals,] on killing - hunted; tam dvijam = for him, the bird; saH = he; anutastaara = spread sacred grass - to place offerings.Then that resolute Rama on going into forest along with Soumitri hunted a robust-bodied, big Rohi animal, or, Kesari animal, and then he spread sacred grass on ground to place that offering to the deceased soul of that bird. Did Rama eat meat, and why is it relevant to contemporary India? The latter is also an utmost devotee of Ramas, and had hosted him for a while. Hence, there is no question of Shri Ram being a non-vegetarian. Sita wanted it as a pet to bring back to Ayodhya; here's what she tells Rama in this chapter of the Aranya Kanda of the Ramayana: Oh, nobleman's son, that delightful deer is stealing my heart, oh, dextrous one, bring it round, it will be our plaything. Browse other questions tagged, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. It has been edited from the original version. Animals can die in forest because of any reason. of the genus Herpestes, Marathi manguus]; varaahaan ca = wild-boars, also; hatvaa = on killing; bahu amiSaan aadaaya = aplenty, meat, on taking; puSkalam vanyam aadaaya = plentiful, forest produce, on taking; aagamiSyati = will be coming [soon. Clarifies many doubts. Another reference that is commonly . thank you very much . So what the Goddess likes is the red color. Whether golden, amber, red or black, they had no interest in bringing it back. I think Shree Raam went out to kill a deer. Pls see kindle version of book here. Read whole chapter Here. Some argued with me stating that he relied on fruits, herbs and roots only. We need to look at the Ramayana written by Vaalmiki. Where is it said that Kshatriyas are allowed to hunt in Vedas? Newbie Ubuntu 22.04.2 on thumb drive "symbol 'grub_file_filters' not found". Now, one should not misinterpret the above to mean one cannot do yoga without getting a deerskin first, and ignoring other more important instructions. Muslims are made sacrificial lambs on the altar of democracy in India, The forced evictions across India around G20 events, U.S. And UK Are Industrialized Worlds Least-trusted Governments, Finds Poll, IMSD condemns caste-based discrimination by a Kerala mosque, Comrade DV Rao: Resist Caste Atrocities Militantly, Dumping Doubts: Releasing Fukushimas Waste Water, Why Use of Cluster Bombs for Liberating Territory Implies Serious Self-Harm Too, French nuclear reactors for Jaitapur in Maharashtra- Expensive & Risky- Appeal for caution, China And Russia Should Lead Global Governance Reform, Suggests Xi, Making a Difference Together: Social Media Giving Day is Here, Feasibility of Idea of Uniform Civil Code is Under Question, Being Free Means Getting Climate Reparations Rightbut Not Everyone Is Onboard, In Chile, Having a Good Constitution Doesnt Guarantee Social Change. He is abstaining from variety of things - one of them is said to be the meat. a sharp arrow, just as Lord iva killed Daka.SB 9.10.10, || -- :: Sita was enraptured by the dazzling golden deer and entreated Rama to get it for her. Sage Agasthya ate meat during a ritual where Pitru Karma is performed. objects. 13,117.038c ahis parama mitram ahis parama sukham 13,116.073c janmaprabhti madya ca sarve te munaya smt. Many kings in ancient days, O son of Pritha, who had constituted themselves the souls of all creatures and who were conversant with the truths of all things, viz., Soul and Not-soul, had abstained from flesh either for the whole of the month of Karttika or for the whole of the lighted fortnight in that month. || --. So the idea is, is it that God is so foolish that He doesnt understand what is a real animal and what is a flour animal? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. So . Why translate this word only to mean meat? ; yajasva = worship; devataaH = the deities; asi ahi = you are indeed; kushalaH = skilled (in such act), "This black antelope, with its complete limbs, has been cooked completely by me. adhrya carma me sadbh romyasthi ca varjitam, abhakyi ca msni tvadvidhairdharmacribhi ||4.17.37, My skin is not fit to be worn by the virtuous, my hair and bones are also prohibited from any use. Lord Rama - A vegetarian? He turned out to be Maarich. 29. vatsyaami = I shall live vane = in forest; vijane = bereft of people munivat = like sage chaturdasha = fourteen varshhaaNi = years hitvaa = leaving off aamishham = meat; jiivan = living madhu muulaphalaiH = with honey; roots and fruits. Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood. Lakshmana will reverentially offer them to you on skewering them with arrow, and on broiling them on iron rod of arrow after descaling and de-finning them. four forms as the sons of Mahrja Daaratha. What's the worst meat to eat? There is no reference of anyone offering liquor to Mother Ganges so it is astonishing why would Mother Sita offer such thing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7RGLr8Oka8. Why is that so many apps today require MacBook with a M1 chip? Mamsa can refer to meat directly but it is also known to refer to other things. Hinduism doesn't favour violence or killing innocent beings. 34;35. raaghavau = Rama and Lakshmana; saha siitauyaa = along with Seetha; shubha lakshhmaNau = having auspicious characterstics; tarpayitvaa = satisfied; bhuutaani = the spirits; maalyaiH = by crowns of flowers; vanyaiH = obtained in the forest; phalaiH = by fruits; mulaiH = by roots; pakvaiH = by cooked; maamsaiH = meat; abdhiH = by water; japaishcha = by prayers; vedoktaiH = as uttered in sacred texts (Vedas); darbhaishcha = by sacred grass; sasmitkuchaiH = by fuel and Kusa grass; tadaa = then; vivishatuH = entered; sushubhaam = the auspicious; shaalaam = leaf-hut. *DID LORD RAMA EAT MEAT* Some people feel so. Each may contradict with one another. There is nothing on earth that is superior to flesh in point of taste. Lord Ramachandra ate meat!? - ISKCON desire tree Dr. Shuaib Sayyed, Research Manager, Islam and Comparative Religion, (IRF) says, "It is mentioned in Ayodhya Khandam chapter 20, 26 and 94 that when Rama was sent for Banavas he told his mother that he would have to sacrifice his tasty meat dishes. | vadhasya = of killing - about hunting; a kovidaaH = not, experts - artless to avoid hunting; shubhaaH = best - birds; naraan dR^iSTvaa = people, on seeing; na udvijante = un, flustered; ghR^ita piNDa upamaan = ghee, gobs, in simile; sthuulaan taan dvijaan = burly, them, birds; bhakSayiSyathaH = you may savour. Abstention from cruelty is the highest gift is the highest penance. Verse 5:36:41 says "Rama is not eating meat, nor indulging even in spirituous liquor. How long did Lord Rama lived? We often tag it as a vegetarian religion. Not the Ramayana which was edited in recent times to suit the needs of certain Hindu groups. It has to be taken wisely to eat meat or not. We often tag it as a vegetarian religion. Also the animals that are excellent in their form, say monkeys, are moving here. Lord Savitr (Sun-god) helps them in their journey., [The commentator quotes the sruti and smrti to show that Rama did not commit any sin when he got a deer killed for the rituals of house-warming. Lord Rama Story Rama was the elder son of King Dasharath of Ayodhya. He was an ideal king of all time. How to wash away sin after unconsciously consuming non-vegetarian food? Is consuming non vegetarian food allowed in case of survival? Rama did not eat INDUSTRIAL-FACTORY FARMED meat Does Iowa have more farmland suitable for growing corn and wheat than Canada? [3-68-32], |, || --, 33. mahaayashaaH = highly renowned one - for his observance of religious ceremonies; raamaH = Rama; rohi maamsaani = Rohi animal's, meat; uddhR^itya = pulling out; peshii kR^itvaa = to gobbets, on lumping it; ramye harita shaadvale = on pleasant, greenish, on pastures; shakunaaya dadau = for the bird [Jataayu,] gave [as offering. It will be surprising if this deer draws into your capture alive and well, as it creates astonishment to one and all. Caution for sanctioned meat-eaters is that meat should be consumed only on some days. So from these some people infer that this means that Lord Ram would normally eat meat but in the jungle He decided to stop eating meat. Which is to be done by those who wish to live long. He is the seventh and one of the most popular avatars of Vishnu. So if its a matter of life or death and a person doesnt get anything to eat at that time if a person has to eat an animal flesh that is considered to be an unavoidable thing and so it is accepted. Many Hindus failed to realize the vast differences within Hinduism itself. Asked 9 years ago Modified 5 months ago Viewed 45k times 46 I have always believed that Lord Rama was a vegetarian, but after reading certain blogs I found out that there might be certain verses in Ramayana ( like the one below) which indicate quite the opposite. Isn't your first line contradicting Sita's statement: "I wish to sit along with you on its golden deerskin". It produces great development. Answer: Though many believe that since Shri Ram was a Kshatriya he must have consumed non vegetarian food, however Valmiki Ramayan makes it clear that he had eaten ONLY Sattvic food as per his promise to mother Kaushalya. Another reference that is commonly quoted for saying that Lord Ram ate meat comes in the Ayodhyakand in chapter 20 among the 119th chapter that comprises the Ayodhyakand which is in the 2nd book where Lord Ram is shown to be departing from the forest. 33. tataH = thereafter; gatvaa = having travelled; kroshamaatram = only a couple of miles; bhraatarau = the two brothers; raamalakshhmaNau = Rama and Lakshmana; hatvaa = killed; bahuun = many; medhyaan = consecrated; mR^igaan = deer; cheratuH = and ate; yamunaavane = in the river-forest of Yamuna. To rephrase my question, why are Kshatriyas allowed to hunt, kill animals just for fun. In Sundara KAnDa also, Hanuman tells Sita that Rama has taken no pleasure in meat or madhu since being separated from her. But isn't killing a deer for its golden skin unjustified? Here the Valmiki Ramayana Verses : Lord Says to Mother Kaushalya : > | Recently there was quite a controversy about the free meals being served to poor children being exclusively vegetarian or otherwise. So as you can see, it's only if Rama accidentally kills it in the process of trying to capture it that Sita wants its skin. @YDS Sure. samvasa muhrta tu akya vastumiha tvay3.47.22, gamiyati me bhart vanyamdya pukalam, rurngodh nvarhca hatvdyminbahn3.47.23, Rest here awhile. Hunting, meat-eating, using deerskin as a mat or as a coat to protect oneself from the weather was all normal for forest dwellers. He narrates, hows Rama has lost his appetite, sleep and mood in her excruciatingly worrisome longing, and anxiety. The questions iterate my previous comment. There are many things which Lord Ram has done for imitation. Then, Lakshmana the strong man and son of Sumitra, killing a holy back antelope, tossed it in an ignited fire. Rama and Lakshmana along with Seetha, having auspicious characteristics, satisfied the sirits by crowns of flowers obtained in the forest, by fruits roots and cooked meat, by water, by prayers as uttered in the sacred texts (Vedas), by sacred grass, by fuel and Kusa grass and then entered the auspicious leaf-hut. deer, brought it and spread it as an offering (to the dead Jatayu)., rohimsni cotktya pektya mahya3.68.33. Part 1 The Monks Podcast 206 with Radhika Raman Prabhu, Hindi Adipurusha movie: Ramayana: Modernized or minimized? | Why did Lord Rama ask for the second Pariksha? With those of the last two, Ramas story is the most popular and accessible to the common man, prevalent in preaching and sermons. In the manusamhita, in the original vedic literature there are some references to meat eating because it is a concession. 2. the reference you gave where Mother Sita is promising Suraghata Sura also mean juices not necessarily liquor.. Amruta Kataka comments Rama and Lakshmana killed a she-deer for sacrifice to the gods presiding over the newly built hut. Hence I do not see any reason why he should be a vegetarian. How can Lord rama consume meat without sacrificing it to the dieties first? That's worse than killing it for food. It is to elevate the attached people and thats why if we are fortunate enough to get the conclusive understanding on the final purpose of vedic literature that vedai ca sarvair aham eva vedyo Lord Krishna tells in the Bhagavad Gita 15.15 then one can supersede and reject all those rituals in ones own practice and understand and explain their transitional, contextual purpose to those who are open to hearing it. Lord krishna mentions in gita that it is dharma to be a vegetarian. Five Explanations For The Golden Deer From The Ramayana Due to the deer, ravana was able to kidnap SITA JI, which eventually led to his downfall. And in any case Kshatriyas are allowed to freely hunt animals, as Rama himself tells Vali in this chapter of the Kishkindha Kanda of the Ramayana: In this world even the kingly sages well-versed in virtue will go on hunting, and hunting is no face to face game, as such, oh, vanara, therefore I felled you in combat with my arrow because you are a tree-branch animal, whether you are not combating with me or combating against me. ssss And Not about Whether Shree Rama was aware of Demon or not. Hanuma is telling about, then current condition of Rama as: | Why did the subject of conversation between Gingerbread Man and Lord Farquaad suddenly change? was agitated by lusty desires, and he went to kidnap her. Further, in his commentary, Amruta Kataka writes They killed a spotted deer and a black deer, as they were very hungry. Manu Smriti 5.32. Hinduism Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for followers of the Hindu religion and those interested in learning more about Hinduism. Why are Gods and Yogis shown sitting on animals skins? By such conduct they do not become stained with sin. This verse alludes to the fact that Rama was well-versed with dressing meat. Why is Sita asked for deer? - wisdom-qa.com 9. kroamtra tato gatv bhrtarau rmalakmaau. 1. @AupakaranaAbhibhaa It's not talking about Ram but Raghuvanshi or Lineage of King Raghu. It looks more like a tradition in the clan rather than personal choice of Ram. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. 8. Rama, Sita and Lakshman were living happily in the forest. Very nicely explained ! What is validity of different translation of word" Mamsah"? I find it difficult to believe. Are Tucker's Kobolds scarier under 5e rules than in previous editions? Do thou always speak the truth. 14b, 15, 16a. A Hindu treatise called Manusmriti codifies behavioural norms based on values as celibacy, fidelity, teetotalism, abstinence, austerity, abnegation and vegetarianism. Together with the Vedas, the Upanishads, the Puranas, the Mahabharata, and the Shrimadbhagvadgita, it comprises the prime corpus of Hindu scriptures. Seetha, saying; "This meat is fresh, this is savoury and roasted in Nope. surghaasahasrea msabhtaudanena ca, yakye tv prayat devi pur punarupgat2.52.89, O Devi after my return to Ayodhya purified by my austerities, I shall worship you by offering a thousand pots of nectar and food in the form of meat., This is stated by Sita as a prostration towards the deified, pious Ganga River, pledging myriad offerings, including meat, in lieu of Ramas safe return from his exile. Very nice & detailed explanation. Who knows, in addition to eating standard meats, perhaps both Rama & Sita also ate lizards, turtles, hedgehogs and porcupines. Remember that Ramayana was poetry and hence there would be many metaphoric words which cannot be taken literally. rma-lakmaa-bharata-atrughn iti sajay Meaning - Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator. We are meant to follow His instructions. So it's fair to assume the "deer catching" episode was going to end in killing the deer i.e., it was no accidental killing. The intuitiveness suggests habituation. It is Gita press publication. The golden deer lured Sita, who called Rama and Lakshmana to see it. Now, if people want to believe lord rama was a non vegetarian even after reading this, then god help them. 22. saumitre = Oh; Lakshmana! It is a dharma and there is no possibility of any sin caused by violence. He did not appear on earth for eating his own creations nor he wielded Bow and arrow to Killing them, he wielded it for destruction of demons only. 13,117.037a ahis paramo dharmas tathhis paro dama Pitamber Kaushik is a columnist, journalist and researcher, having previously written in over 40 newspapers in 18 countries. He who eats meat, when he honours the gods and manes, commits no sin, whether he has bought it, or himself has killed (the animal), or has received it as a present from others. Was he a non-vegetarian? She wanted the deer alive as a pet because it was so attractive and when Lord Ram kept chasing and chasing that and in this chasing the deer was mystically appearing and disappearing and suddenly jumping high in the air and jumping down and going here and bounding off in that direction. I'm referring to the incident in Ramayana where Rama hunted the Golden Deer (Mareecha) for its skin. So what he could have eaten in the forest? Can we eat non-veg daily? Can you please confirm who is the translator? Aamisham means meat and it also means enjoyable sense object like kingdom; it also . To hear the answer, please click here Tearing the flesh of the deer to pieces and making them into balls, the celebrated Rama laid it on a lovely, green grassy land as offering to the bird. In the third book, Aranya-kanda, Chapter 43, Mother Sita spots the golden deer and asks Lord Rama to fetch it. Chaitanya Charan content. Rama was the son of Dashrath, king of Ayodhya. First level is if you just look at the context of the Ramayana, it doesnt refer to either the section of the animal deer being killed or Lord Rams statement when He is departing from Ayodhya, they dont support the idea that it refers to meat. They are not quoted here to prevent redundancy. Terms of Service, 2023ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT You can read it towards the end of this article and judge it for yourself. He was exiled. answer - http://www.thespiritualscientist.com/2012/01/do-the-vedic-literatur Report an Issue | He reveals that although Lord Rama is in great sorrow of separation from Mother Sita, He hasn't fallen down to . SO IMO it does not mateer ..Rama knows or not & in both the cases the action is justified. So hittvam eesham if we see the overall context of the Ramayana and the overall theme of vegetarianism and compassion with all living beings based on the understanding that they are all souls- This is the understanding that pervades the vedic literature and based on this understanding it is this understanding of this verse that is most plausible, most compatible, most reasonable. Although Even if Shree Raam knew everything, Shree Raam is purushottam and his every action is an example for all. Srila Prabhupada took a different track and He said that Lord Ram is the Absolute Truth. I remember the last time I met him, almost[Read More]. The OP is asking abt whether killing of deer is justified or not. First off, I don't understand how can one "catch" a deer with a bow & arrow without injuring it somehow or even end up killing it. Oh, lord, the form of this deer creates an excellent jubilation to Bharata, to you the son of the nobleman, to my mothers in law, and also to me in palace chambers. To hear the Hindi answer, please click here Why did Rama try to kill an innocent deer just for its skin? In the last quote, Rama just says that kings go for hunting, he doesn't say that they are allowed to do that or hunting is a good act. Control two leds with only one PIC output, Explaining Ohm's Law and Conductivity's constance at particle level. He can eat the universe if He likes. So that way, this context also doesnt justify the interpretation that Lord Ram ate meat. We shall perform a purifactory ceremony while entering the house. Abstention from cruelty is the highest Religion is the highest self-control. Chapter 3 (Sarga 41) . So this assumption needs adjustment. After much pitch, lord Ram hit that deer with arrows. Feeling certain that it is cooked and heated thoroughly with no blood remaining, Lakshmana spoke to Rama the lion among man as follows: |, || --, 28. ayam = this; kR^iSNaH mR^igo = black antelope; samaapta angaH = with its complete limbs; shR^itaH = has been cooked; sarvaH = completely; mayaa = by me; deva damkaasha = Oh Rama; remsembling god! Sign up below. He can eat the whole universe and still will not be affected. This Website is Under Maintenance. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Of old age? || --, |. Kshatriyas and Sudras are allowed to eat meat. Why Extend Volume is Grayed Out in Server 2016. The mythological epic poem narrates the journey of Rama, a righteous prince (with divine qualities, in some renditions and interpretations), considered the epitome of morality and conduct. These celebrated incarnations thus appeared in After Reading this Im very much pleased and got exact purpose of vedas with logics. 2. Browse other questions tagged, Like any library, Hinduism Stack Exchange shares great information, but, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. One of the hottest debates which I came across was about Lord Rama's diet. Who was killed by Shri Ram in Ramayana? - TimesMojo Aamisham means meat and it also means enjoyable sense object like kingdom; Abstention from cruelty is the highest sacrifice is the highest puissance. In the wild, what are the chances of finding a deer that died of natural causes? Is this color scheme another standard for RJ45 cable? It is by truth that Harischandra roves through heaven like a second Chandramas. Why did Rama hunt deer? obviously not; It is the same; Ramanujacharya and Madhavacharya used to talk about these things and they have talked about the glory of God in various ways. it also means immense sense gratification and very pleasant and dear sense So in a forest it is quite likely that because of lack of foods sometimes, those who are living in the forest may have to resort to the eating of meat. Lord Ram is Visnu-tattva. 2. If we can accept the fact that Draupadi was shared by 5 husbands, why can't we accept the non-vegetarian aspect of Hinduism? There are many references in the Ramayana where Rama, followed by Lakshmana killed animals for their need. So I think, today's Hindus should learn from it to avoid eating meat as there is no more a system of a king ruling a kingdom. If you would like to make a donation to support this website. Also the Ramayana, where during their sojourn in the Dandakaranya forest, Rama, Lakshmana and Sita are said to have relished such rice (with meat and vegetables). can also mean that Raghuvamsi never eat meat nor do they The Ramacaritmanasa by the 16th century poet Tulasidas, also known as the Tulasi Ramayana is much more popular, primarily as it is written in a vernacular dialect of Hindi rather than Sanskrit, and hence is more accessible to the layfolk. He is a model for us to follow in our lives; the way He was a dutiful son and protector of the citizens and as a king the annihilator of miscreants. There is no food, O scorcher of foes, that is superior to flesh. Why is that so many apps today require MacBook with a M1 chip? ", |, || --. atha = then; saH lakshmaNaH = that Lakshmana; prataapavaan = the strong man; saumitriH = and son of Sumitra; hatvaa = killing; medhyam = the holy; kR^iSNa mR^igam = black antelope; chikSepa = tossed; jaata vedasi = in a fire; samiddhe = ignited.
Landmark At Pine Court Apartments Columbia, Sc,
Las Vegas Pride Parade,
Villa Palm Livermore Ca For Rent,
Yuba College Homepage,
Broomfield School District Calendar 2023,
Articles D